Comments on: Performance Not Timing Should Be Lieberthal’s Legacy in Philadelphia http://seamheads.com/2008/05/31/performance-not-timing-should-be-lieberthal%e2%80%99s-legacy-in-philadelphia/ Tue, 22 May 2012 12:58:57 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.2 By: Brian Joseph http://seamheads.com/2008/05/31/performance-not-timing-should-be-lieberthal%e2%80%99s-legacy-in-philadelphia/comment-page-1/#comment-1662 Brian Joseph Mon, 02 Jun 2008 01:58:21 +0000 http://seamheads.com/blog/2008/05/31/performance-not-timing-should-be-lieberthal%e2%80%99s-legacy-in-philadelphia/#comment-1662 You can actually click on the stats to make them readable on a separate view... and when I was going through the information, I figured it was Boone, Daulton and Lieberthal who could be argued as the best. Personally, I rank them this way: OFFENSE 1. Lieberthal 2. Daulton 3. Boone DEFENSE 1. Boone 2. Lieberthal 3. Daulton LEADERSHIP 1. Boone 2. Daulton 3. Lieberthal I think it's a tough call between Lieberthal and Boone but not an easy one. Boone had a better career but that includes the success he had after he left Philly. Daulton's legacy was inflated (as all the '93 player's legacies were) by the hype around that team. if all three players were available to me, I'd begrudgingly take Boone over Lieberthal but only b/c I'd have to hold a press conference and face the public based on my decision. LOL :)<div class="comment-remix-meta"><a href="#" class="replyto" onclick="replyto('1662','Brian Joseph'); return false;">Reply</a> - <a href="#" class="quote" onclick="quote('1662','Brian Joseph','You can actually click on the stats to make them readable on a separate view... and when I was going through the information, I figured it was Boone, Daulton and Lieberthal who could be argued as the best. Personally, I rank them this way:\r\n\r\nOFFENSE\r\n1. Lieberthal\r\n2. Daulton\r\n3. Boone\r\n\r\nDEFENSE\r\n1. Boone\r\n2. Lieberthal\r\n3. Daulton\r\n\r\nLEADERSHIP\r\n1. Boone\r\n2. Daulton\r\n3. Lieberthal\r\n\r\nI think it\'s a tough call between Lieberthal and Boone but not an easy one. Boone had a better career but that includes the success he had after he left Philly. Daulton\'s legacy was inflated (as all the \'93 player\'s legacies were) by the hype around that team.\r\n\r\nif all three players were available to me, I\'d begrudgingly take Boone over Lieberthal but only b\/c I\'d have to hold a press conference and face the public based on my decision. LOL :)'); return false;">Quote</a></div> You can actually click on the stats to make them readable on a separate view… and when I was going through the information, I figured it was Boone, Daulton and Lieberthal who could be argued as the best. Personally, I rank them this way:

OFFENSE
1. Lieberthal
2. Daulton
3. Boone

DEFENSE
1. Boone
2. Lieberthal
3. Daulton

LEADERSHIP
1. Boone
2. Daulton
3. Lieberthal

I think it’s a tough call between Lieberthal and Boone but not an easy one. Boone had a better career but that includes the success he had after he left Philly. Daulton’s legacy was inflated (as all the ’93 player’s legacies were) by the hype around that team.

if all three players were available to me, I’d begrudgingly take Boone over Lieberthal but only b/c I’d have to hold a press conference and face the public based on my decision. LOL :)

Reply – Quote
]]> By: Greg http://seamheads.com/2008/05/31/performance-not-timing-should-be-lieberthal%e2%80%99s-legacy-in-philadelphia/comment-page-1/#comment-1661 Greg Mon, 02 Jun 2008 01:39:30 +0000 http://seamheads.com/blog/2008/05/31/performance-not-timing-should-be-lieberthal%e2%80%99s-legacy-in-philadelphia/#comment-1661 another interesting article, I am eager to hear your personal opinion on who the best catcher offensively was for the Phillies. I would have to go with Dutch, despite on paper playing for a year longer than Lieby, he had 600 less AB's and if i get the magnifying glass out i think i can read that on average he would have better power numbers. I think Lieby really lacked some leadership skills or he could have been liked a whole lot more in Philly and to be honest maybe he would have been a bit more clutch if he felt the team was on his shoulders...<div class="comment-remix-meta"><a href="#" class="replyto" onclick="replyto('1661','Greg'); return false;">Reply</a> - <a href="#" class="quote" onclick="quote('1661','Greg','another interesting article, I am eager to hear your personal opinion on who the best catcher offensively was for the Phillies. I would have to go with Dutch, despite on paper playing for a year longer than Lieby, he had 600 less AB\'s and if i get the magnifying glass out i think i can read that on average he would have better power numbers. \r\n\r\nI think Lieby really lacked some leadership skills or he could have been liked a whole lot more in Philly and to be honest maybe he would have been a bit more clutch if he felt the team was on his shoulders...'); return false;">Quote</a></div> another interesting article, I am eager to hear your personal opinion on who the best catcher offensively was for the Phillies. I would have to go with Dutch, despite on paper playing for a year longer than Lieby, he had 600 less AB’s and if i get the magnifying glass out i think i can read that on average he would have better power numbers.

I think Lieby really lacked some leadership skills or he could have been liked a whole lot more in Philly and to be honest maybe he would have been a bit more clutch if he felt the team was on his shoulders…

Reply – Quote
]]>