seamheads NegroLg BBGauge
History
All-Time
Links
Gary Ashwill Wikipedia NLBPA The Baseball Page
Scott Simkus BR Bullpen Black Baseball Baseball-Fever
MLB.com SABR Negro League Baseball  
Negro League Museum SABR Bio Project Negro League Legends  

Hall of Famers vs Non-Hall of Famers

American Hall of Fame
# Pos  
WAR
WS
WSAB
1
CF
  
51.1
237.3
157.0
2
CF
  
50.8
215.4
135.5
3
SP
  
49.7
208.4
104.2
4
CF
  
48.9
199.3
126.8
5
SS
  
44.7
184.1
101.0
6
SP
  
41.3
160.5
98.2
7
1B
  
30.7
148.5
80.6
8
SP
  
43.5
144.8
79.0
9
SP
  
18.0
96.7
52.6
10
C
  
18.9
80.7
41.2
11
CF
  
13.2
70.1
47.0
12
C
  
15.7
66.4
31.2
13
SP
  
11.1
62.4
28.4
14
CF
  
11.4
51.9
18.3
15
SP
  
8.6
45.3
27.7
16
1B
  
7.1
40.8
22.2
17
1B
  
9.2
38.5
24.5
18
SS
  
7.4
36.5
20.2
19
3B
  
6.1
33.6
6.4
20
SP
  
8.5
28.4
19.6
21
C
  
3.9
15.6
11.0
22
SP
  
2.7
15.5
3.6
23
SP
  
1.8
8.5
4.7
24
2B
  
0.2
1.5
0.1
25
SS
  
-0.4
0.4
-0.9
26
Hank Aaron
 
27
Ernie Banks
 
28
Willard Brown
 
29
Roy Campanella
 
30
Leon Day
 
31
Larry Doby
 
32
Monte Irvin
 
33
Buck Leonard
 
34
Willie Mays
 
35
Jackie Robinson
 
36
Hilton Smith
 
Cuban Hall of Fame
# Pos   WAR WS WSAB
1
CF
  
51.1
237.3
157.0
2
SP
  
49.7
208.4
104.2
3
SP
  
25.4
116.5
55.8
4
C
  
20.8
104.5
38.3
5
3B
  
24.4
100.2
51.6
6
RF
  
13.7
87.6
28.7
7
1B
  
19.2
87.6
54.3
8
CF
  
12.7
76.9
23.1
9
SS
  
11.6
76.8
16.8
10
C
  
16.6
75.4
34.4
11
SP
  
16.9
73.5
38.2
12
LF
  
12.5
71.6
31.8
13
RF
  
10.4
68.0
32.4
14
SS
  
10.9
62.8
15.7
15
LF
  
15.1
62.0
24.4
16
CF
  
13.1
60.3
22.2
17
3B
  
10.2
50.2
14.4
18
2B
  
7.7
49.7
9.4
19
LF
  
2.1
48.8
3.7
20
2B
  
6.9
43.9
6.3
21
CF
  
9.4
42.4
14.5
22
SS
  
5.8
41.2
2.9
23
SP
  
7.5
40.6
16.2
24
SP
  
5.6
38.3
19.6
25
CF
  
5.9
36.2
10.6
26
SS
  
3.0
28.8
5.5
27
SP
  
4.2
27.9
13.1
28
CF
  
5.1
26.3
11.3
29
RF
  
0.7
25.0
-8.3
30
SP
  
2.2
23.2
4.2
31
LF
  
5.5
23.0
11.5
32
CF
  
6.1
22.9
11.2
33
3B
  
4.2
22.7
9.2
34
C
  
-1.8
22.3
-3.1
35
C
  
4.2
21.7
7.7
36
LF
  
2.9
16.3
3.4
37
SP
  
2.7
15.5
3.6
38
C
  
-1.6
8.1
-6.3
39
3B
  
0.9
4.7
1.1
40
1B
  
-1.0
2.9
-2.3
41
RF
  
0.7
2.8
2.2
42
C
  
-0.8
0.3
-1.0
43
1B
  
-0.3
0.2
-0.3
44
Juan Antiga
 
45
Alfredo Arango
 
46
Ramón Bragańa
 
47
Ricardo Cabaleiro
 
48
Román Calzadilla
 
49
Tomás de la Cruz
 
50
Wenceslao Gálvez
 
51
Nemesio Guilló
 
52
Rafael Hernández
 
53
Eugenio Jiménez
 
54
Julio López
 
55
Adolfo Lujan
 
56
Eduardo Machado
 
57
Carlos Maciá
 
58
Ricardo Martínez
 
59
Juan Pastoriza
 
60
Francsico Poyo
 
61
Oscar Rodríguez
 
62
Pablo Ronquillo
 
63
Emilio Sabourín
 
64
Jose Teuma
 
65
Arturo Valdés
 
66
Carlos Zaldo
 
Non-Hall of Famers
# Pos   WAR WS WSAB
1
SP
  
42.5
183.7
68.7
2
SP
  
31.3
150.2
69.4
3
LF
  
22.6
107.4
54.9
4
SP
  
25.4
96.4
46.7
5
SP
  
18.6
96.3
44.0
6
SP
  
18.9
89.1
26.3
7
LF
  
16.6
88.3
42.2
8
2B
  
13.0
87.1
25.8
9
SP
  
14.1
86.3
47.3
10
SP
  
14.6
85.5
32.9
11
LF
  
16.6
85.2
39.6
12
3B
  
13.3
83.5
31.5
13
SP
  
12.9
83.1
29.8
14
2B
  
19.9
80.2
43.7
15
RF
  
10.5
79.8
29.3
16
SS
  
19.9
79.6
43.1
17
SP
  
12.6
79.2
19.2
18
SP
  
17.3
78.9
47.0
19
SP
  
14.0
77.8
44.4
20
SP
  
10.4
73.9
28.5
21
SP
  
13.6
72.2
25.2
22
SP
  
16.4
72.0
22.3
23
RF
  
15.7
70.7
35.5
24
SP
  
15.0
70.5
23.2
25
2B
  
12.1
68.2
15.7
26
SP
  
16.0
68.1
27.3
27
C
  
8.7
67.7
4.8
28
RF
  
16.2
66.5
41.5
29
SP
  
13.9
64.6
38.0
30
SP
  
10.3
63.8
35.2
31
3B
  
9.2
62.9
19.8
32
SP
  
10.1
62.6
21.8
33
SP
  
14.6
62.2
28.6
34
LF
  
7.0
62.1
17.4
35
SP
  
11.7
60.6
21.5
36
SP
  
12.9
60.4
26.2
37
SS
  
13.6
59.9
30.2
38
1B
  
12.0
59.0
32.0
39
CF
  
13.9
58.5
23.5
40
CF
  
8.0
58.4
23.9
41
SP
  
6.7
58.4
22.5
42
SS
  
9.8
57.6
10.5
43
1B
  
12.3
57.3
31.4
44
SP
  
14.1
56.6
18.0
45
3B
  
4.1
56.5
-0.6
46
LF
  
7.0
55.2
13.9
47
SP
  
9.7
55.0
29.6
48
CF
  
12.5
54.1
26.0
49
SS
  
5.4
53.6
-4.4
50
SP
  
12.0
53.5
20.8

Any questions, comments, suggestions? Please contact the webmaster at BaseballGauge@gmail.com

Statistical and biographical data for the The Negro Leagues Database, except 1923 and 1933, were compiled by Gary Ashwill. Copyright 2011-2013 Gary Ashwill. All rights reserved. Playing statistics for 1923 were compiled by Patrick Rock. Copyright 2011-2013 Patrick Rock. All rights reserved. Playing statistics for 1933 were compiled by Scott Simkus. Copyright 2013 Scott Simkus. All rights reserved.

Win Shares are calculated using the formula in the book Win Shares by Bill James