An Early Look at Agent of the Year
March 15, 2009 by Ted Leavengood · Leave a Comment
Evaluating off-season signings by Major League Baseball teams is like predicting the bottom of the recession. It can only be done in retrospect, after the facts are known. But both are economic analysis and Jon Heyman’s recent article on this year’s crop fails that course, unless you understand his thesis as a paean to every fan’s worst enemy, the sports agent.
On page two of Heyman’s SI article he ranks the best free agent signings of the off-season. He adds in the small print a criteria for “best agenting jobs of the winter.” It is only within that context that you can understand Edgar Renteria as the best signing of the year, and include A. J. Burnett and Carl Pavano in the top five. After giving deserved praise to White Sox GM Ken Williams on page one, the question on page two might have been what were the other GMs thinking? How many of them will be called on the carpet at the end of the year for these out-sized contracts after fans have endured a season of petulant under-performance and gimpy elder citizens who do not warrant the big paydays.
Defining market value is a daunting task and one that often defies quick or easy characterization. The real estate bromide, “location, location, location,” may be instructive. The value of C.C. Sabathia and Mark Teixeira to the Yankees ownership can only be calculated in New York City’s unique and curious economic environment. The Steinbrenners reputedly have spent close to $1.6 billion in taxpayer financing to build their throwback to the gilded age of derivative financing–New Yankee Stadium. The downside risk for the Yankees is that grossly inflated ticket prices to watch a losing team might alienate the fan base and make re-paying the bonds dicey.
So signing one of the best offensive players in Teixeira and one of the most durable pitchers in Sabathia may make imminent investment sense. It may prove to be good value for the money. But Heyman ranks their signing at #7 and #8 respectively, while Raul Ibanez comes in at #9. The overall effect confuses slightly. The work of Burnett’s agent, Derek Braunecker, is credit worthy–so to speak–but surely the work for Ibanez is worth more than that of Scott Boras. Selling gems in New York City is a time-honored tradition and easy by comparison.
First let me say that calling out agents other than Scott Boras and spreading the wealth is a good thing. Jon Heyman is getting much deserved attention for the accomplishments of lesser known agents like Tom O’Connell. He landed Carl Pavano $1.5 million despite Carl’s ability to pitch only a total of 144 innings over the past four years, or get his ERA under 4.47. Those mediocre stats and worrying health reports for Pavano, who is also 33, make good return on the dollar very risky. Heyman rightly terms O’Connell a “miracle worker,” recalling the 1960’s era movie where the blind were made to see.
But why Renteria at number one? He takes the place of Omar Vizquel who at 41 makes Renteria look fresh and youthful. With Ray Durham’s departure as well, the Giants ability to field the oldest infield in the majors was in jeopardy so perhaps Renteria can be understood in those terms. They still have Benjie Molina, who like Renteria is 34. So getting close to $10 million a year for two-years for a shortstop whose diminishing defensive and offensive skills puts him in the bottom half of his peer group is noteworthy. But number #1? Renteria’s agent Barry Meister deserves credit certainly, but not the top prize.
Those accolades should go to Sam and Seth Levinson for landing 37-year old Raul Ibanez three years and $31.5 million. At this point in the contest it appears to be beyond dispute. David Montgomery and the other Philadelphia owners of the team had to have been so overcome with World Championship emotion that they could not contain themselves. Ibanez is at an age where he might realistically be converted into a platoon DH. He does not have the consistent power of departing Pat Burrell and is five years older. Ibanez has never been a gazelle in the outfield and by the third year of this deal he will be 40. By then the bleacher fans in Philly may make his early retirement seem a blessing.
I can agree that A.J. Burnett’s agent, Braunecker comes in number two. As Heyman notes in the article, “A Marlins person called Yankees GM Brian Cashman to warn him about Burnett’s eccentricities, …(he) has the ability to stub his toe and be out two months.” More importantly, after obligating $45 million in annual revenue to two marquee players, why did the Yankees really need Burnett? Because they missed Carl Pavano? Or did they need to rub the noses of every other team and fan base in their gluttony.
I am picking the latter. The Damn Yankees earn their way in this world and you have to tip your hat to them for their consistency. And that is why Braunecker is only #2 and may deserve only third place. Getting money out of the Steinbrenners to make the rest of us angry is too easy to deserve the top prize. The worst signings look like Ibanez and Pavano, but there is still a lot of baseball left to play.









