November 17, 2026

Money Talks

April 7, 2010 by · Leave a Comment 

USA Today released the 2010 Major League Baseball Salaries in an easy-to-use database.  There is no better predictive model than what the money says.  Put any statistical package up against it and the money flow stacks up pretty well.  

It is hardly surprising that the Yankees are still big dog on the block when it comes to money. They went over $200 million in payroll in 2005 and have held at that level ever since.  With the Mets and Dodgers slipping backwards, the Red Sox return to second in overall payroll at $162 million.  The Red Sox worked hard to achieve that milestone, spending more freely than in recent years on free agents.

The Yankees and Red Sox payrolls are so far ahead of every one else, they must be the best two teams in baseball for 2010.  In two games of head-to-head match up it is hard to argue with that analysis.  The Red Sox invested an additional $41 million in payroll when almost half of all teams were cutting back.  It is the largest increase by any team and it moved Boston closer to the Yankees than any team has come in recent years.

For the past few years the Mets came as close as any other team to the Yankees. They failed to make that work, so it will be interesting to see how well Boston fares.

The real story is in what teams have fallen off the pace.  In Cleveland for example, payroll declined by $20 million, taking the team from mid-tier team to bottom feeding.  I remember hearing around Florida that Manny Acta took the job in Cleveland over Houston because he liked the team there more.  The claim squares with reality because he definitely is not getting more money from the Indians.

Both of the Los Angeles teams reduced team salary noticeably as did other west teams like Seattle.  Seattle is perceived as having had a successful off-season with the addition of top names like Cliff Lee, but they did it while dropping their overall salary commitments.

There are some surprises in the other direction.  Minnesota, one of two favorite small market teams, has hit the jackpot somewhere.  The Twins hiked their payroll to $96 million, going from seventh lowest salary–$65 million–to tenth highest.  Joe Mauer’s signing is the main culprit, but the team added free agents like Orlando Hudson and Jim Thome when before they have been happy with home grown talent like Nick Punto.  If memory serves, there was a time last season when pundits were predicting Mauer would be wearing pin stripes by now.

As the USA Today article asserts, the trend in overall team salaries is down, even though average player salary is about the same.  Big jumps by teams like the Red Sox offset the fourteen teams who cut payroll and the half dozen teams who stayed about the same.  In the biggest economic downturn in years, salaries are stagnant yet the Major League Baseball Players union is debating filing a claim of collusion. That may be a tough sell.

If the Divisional races follow the money they will look as follows:

The NL East will go to the Phillies.  They increased salary by $28 million.  The only other team to increase their payroll substantially was the Marlins who climbed out of the cellar by spending an additional $20 million.  New York and Atlanta spent much less than last year and the Nationals are treading water.

In the NL Central the Cardinals and Cubs spent more.  The Brewers and Reds maintained the status quo, while the Astros and Pirates cut back.  The Cardinals increased their investment more as a percentage and should be the favorites.  The Pirates now are the lowest payroll in the game, taking over from the Marlins.

In the NL West the Giants and Rockies have invested big bucks in 2010 and Joe Morgan was all over the Giants as the dark horse favorites on Sunday night.  The Giants bumped payroll by $16 million and the numbers say that Joe is right.  However, the Rockies cannot be dismissed, having spent 12 percent more this season compared to last.

In the American League East, you have to love the Red Sox.  Their 33 percent jump in payroll is not to be trifled with.  The Orioles and Rays spent more and both will be competitive, but in this division that will get you respect and little more.  Given the shape of the Blue Jays and their sharp reduction in spending, respect is not a bad thing.

In the AL Central Minnesota has to be the favorite with their big jump in dollar outlays.  The Tigers are still there as are the White Sox.  Both teams increased payroll in a down market, so they will be contenders, maybe even for the Wild Card. If  either the Royals or the Indians are contenders, the meek will have finally come into their inheritance.

The AL West is a depressed area that needs TARP funds.  Seattle, Los Angeles, Oakland and Texas cut their payrolls significantly.  Only the Padres and Pirates are below Texas and Oakland in overall salary.  The Angels cut their payroll the least as a percentage and they win in the worst division in baseball.

Speak Your Mind

Tell us what you're thinking...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!