Near Miss League-NL West Preview
May 9, 2009 by Ted Leavengood · Leave a Comment
The NL West of the Near Miss League (NML) sets up several historic rivalries. The Cubbies and the Cards may be the most intense, but in the end the Braves and the Cardinals are most likely to be tangling for the division championship. The Braves pitching–Maddux, Smoltz and Glavine–versus Pujols, Edmonds and Rolen in one of the most potent lineups of any Cardinal team in history. But there will be many great contenders.
Odds-On Favorite:Â 1996 Atlanta Braves
The NL West features several very strong teams who failed to win it all, but maybe should have. The first is the 1996 Atlanta Braves who were NL champs, but lost in the World Series to the Derek Jeter/Bernie Williams/Paul O’Neil Yankees who were renting Cecil Fielder that year.
Atlanta had their famous threesome of Greg Maddux, Tom Glavine, and John Smoltz, but had an even more impressive lineup. Chipper Jones batted third and Fred McGriff backed him up. It was the year that Ryan Klesko finally delivered on a potential long in the making. He had his best season with 34 homers playing left field.
They had another great player in David Justice, similarly at his prime, but he injured himself early in the season and Bobby Cox had to substitute a young player named Jermaine Dye in right field. He showed flashes of brilliance that year, but with Justice returning the next year, Dye moved on to Kansas City.
The team was strong up the middle with Marquis Grissom in center field and Javy Lopez behind the plate. Grissom was the lead off hitter and still a fine center fielder in the prime of his career. Andruw Jones was a 19-year old rookie getting his first taste of the major leagues. Javy Lopez was a fan favorite who did it all, handling a great pitching staff, and hitting for power and average as well.
The only weakness on the team was the relatively mundane double-play combination of Jeff Blauser and Mark Lemke. Lemke was the stronger of the two and Bobby Cox batted him second, hiding Blauser at the back end of the order.
Greg Maddux had won the Cy Young in 1994 and 1995 and was considered the ace of the staff, but in 1996, John Smoltz won the Cy Young with 24 wins. Glavine, Smoltz, and Maddux all pitched to ERAs under 3 runs. Steve Avery was their golfing partner who pitched reasonably well as the fourth starter. Mark Wohlers was the closer and Greg McMichael set him up.
From top to bottom it is a strong team, but in a simulation it is hard to imagine any set of random numbers that would have the entire Atlanta pitching staff struggling. Overall the Braves do too many things extremely well and should compete against their perennial rivals the St. Louis Cardinals for division leadership. It may depend upon the jockeys and whether Greco-Melnick can get more out of their horses than Derrick Goold.
Tight Finishers:Â 2004 St. Louis Cardinals
I like Tony LaRussa managing any team with Dave Duncan handling the pitching, but I doubt the simulation can factor that. So the Cardinals pitching staff is just too middling to compete with the Braves over the course of the season. But the lineup has more power than any other in the division.
Albert Pujols may be one of the most potent offensive forces to play the game and pass a drug test in several decades. In 2004 his 46 homers are surpassed only by his 51 doubles and the amazing 1.072 OPS–low by his standards. As complete a ballplayer as Pujols was and is, Jim Edmonds patrolling in center field even at 34 years of age was a close second. His 1.061 OPS was a close second as well.
With Edgar Renteria at shortstop and Scott Rolen at third, the lineup of complete ballplayers is hard to match. Tony Womack and Mike Matheny were the rest of the infield and better by far than Lemke and Blauser. But the outfield after Edmonds was a bit weak. Reggie Sanders was a good right fielder who had a fine year, but bringing in Larry Walker at the trading deadline made the team complete, except for the pitching.
Jason Marquis and Chris Carpenter were excellent in 2004. Woody Williams, Matt Morris and Jeff Suppan rounded out the rotation and Jason Isringhausen was the closer. What the rotation lacked, the bullpen added as Julian Tavarez, Ray King and Steve Kline were excellent all year long. But on balance, the team does not look as strong on paper as the 1996 Braves.
Best of the Rest:Â Â 1969 Chicago Cubs
Leo “the Lip†Durocher fields his best Cubs team ever in 1969. They have a very strong pitching staff with Ferguson Jenkins and Bill Hands. The offense has five starters with the ability to hit 20+ homers.
In years past Ernie Banks was good for thirty or 40 homers, but even at 38 years of age, he still leads one of the great infields to play the game. Banks is at first base now and Don Kessinger is in his third season as full-time shortstop. But he is a good one and with Glenn Beckert at second base they form a wonderfully deft double-play combination. Ron Santo is the power behind the throne at third and though 1968 saw his production fall for the first season ever, the Cubs believe he will have a big year in 1969.
Billy Williams joins Ron Santo in the middle of the lineup and he is coming off one of his best years. He hit 30 homers last season and is always near the top of the league in triples. He is a delight to watch on the base paths and in the outfield. He will be joined this year by a platoon of Willie Smith and Don Young in center, and Al Spangler and Jim Hickman in right. Randy Hundley catches and he is one of the best in the NL. He played in almost every game last year and it may have worn him down as his power numbers were off. He will bounce back to have a big year in 1969.
Fergie Jenkins is coming off two straight 20-win seasons. He struck out 260 in just over 300 innings. Bill Hands won 16 games in 1968 and had a fine 2.89 ERA. He provides another reliable starter and with young Ken Holtzman rounding into form, they should give the Cubs one of the best starting rotations in the NL. A balance of pitching, defense and a powerful lineup should make the 1969 Cubs a powerful force in the league.
Dark Horse Possibilities:Â Â 1998 Houston Astros
The 1998 Houston Astros had Biggio and Bagwell in their prime, but they had one of their strongest supporting casts. Moises Alou had a huge year with 38 homers and his partners in the outfield, Carl Everett and Derek Bell also played well that year. The pitching was only so-so. Shane Reynolds won 19 games that season and had help from Jose Lima and a young Mike Hampton just coming into his own.  The big story was Randy Johnson who left Seattle and began his run of dominance in the National League. He got eleven starts for the Astros and his presence could make this team able to compete with the big boys at the top.
Running With the Pack: 1998 San Diego Padres Â
In the year that Mark McGwire hit 70 homeruns, Greg Vaughn reached the zenith of his own career with 50. He was the offense and Kevin Brown was the best defense they had. He threw 257 innings of 2.38 baseball and won 18 games to lead
San Diego to the NL Championship and the World Series where they were dispatched in four games. He was closed out by Trevor Hoffman who had 53 saves and a 1.48 ERA.Â
San Diego was a little one-nighter for Kevin Brown traveling on up the coast to the Dodgers and then the Yankees. But he anchored a rotation that included Andy Ashby at his best, and career years for Andy Ashby and Sterling Hitchcock. Hitchcock’s best was “Rear Window,†and Sterling’s career would last another six years as team-after-team looked back over their shoulders paid him hoping for the below-4 ERA he had in 1998. Vaughn had Ken Caminiti, a 38-year old Tony Gwynn, and Steve Finley. It was a good team, but not a great team. Â
It will be interesting to see whether the 1999 Greg Vaughn has a better supporting cast in Cincinnati or the 1998 Greg Vaughn in San Diego. I would push my chips into the middle for Kevin Brown and Trevor Hoffman, but the Reds had a lot of power, so we will just have to wait and see.Â
100-to-One Odds:Â 1999 Cincinnati Reds
They had power and speed to burn, but they were unable to win the division with a pitching staff led by Pete Harnisch. They lost the division to the Astros by half a game and the wild card to the Mets by a game. A great offensive team led by Greg Vaughn at the peak of his career, but mediocre pitching will doom them unless random numbering can make something happen that was never meant to be.
The 1999 Greg Vaughn had only 45 home runs, but he played on a team where 11 players had double-digit homers. Dimitri Young and Michael Tucker platooned and together hit 25 homers. Mike Cameron established himself as a great center fielder who finally had learned to hit. Ace Pete Harnisch was a good pitcher, but he was not a legitimate number one starter, nor was anyone else on the Reds’ staff–Brett Tomko, Steve Parris and Ron Villone.Â
The ninth inning was a closer-du-jour situation with Danny Graves and Scott Williamson getting the lion’s share of the work. But the staff overall is one of the weakest in the division. This team is all about the long ball and in simulation as in real life, the importance of balance cannot be overstated.









