Mayo Smith’s Finest Hour
July 14, 2009 by Ted Leavengood · 1 Comment
Forty years ago–in the 1969 All-Star Game–the American League was managed by the Tigers’ Mayo Smith. He managed the Phillies and the Reds as well as the Tigers, but it was winning the 1968 World Series against a great St. Louis Cardinal team that put him in the dugout for the ’69 All-Star game. Last weekend I had an opportunity to reminisce about the ’68 World Series with Judith Wolfe, Mayo Smith’s daughter. We saw that series from different sides of the fence, but it was fun re-living what was the highlight of her dad’s career and a favorite memory for us both.
A mutual friend brought the Wolfes–Emmett and Judith–to dinner in Port Townsend, Washington knowing that we would all be talking baseball long into the evening. Judith brought her father’s bat given to him by the Detroit players and signed by them all after that World Series Championship win. We rolled the bat around and I marveled at each name–Norm Cash, Dick McAuliffe, Willie Horton–they all brought such great memories back.  What a remarkable team the Tigers had that year to beat the Cardinals at their best.
We recalled how that fall classic had unfolded, how it all came down to that one incredible game between Mickey Lolich and Bob Gibson and how compelling a memory that game remains for both of us.  “After the Tigers went down three games to one, my husband and I pretty much gave up,” admitted Judith. “We went home to Pennsylvania,” she said, leaving Detroit when the series switched back to St. Louis.Â
The Tigers won the fifth game, the last one in Detroit, but Emmett had graduate school to finish and Judith was working, so she decided to listen to whatever was left of the series on the radio.  Bob Gibson had totally dominated the Tigers in his first two games of the series and with Gibby and home field advantage, St. Louis looked like they would walk off with their second straight World Series and third in five years.
“I always preferred to listen to games on the radio anyway,” Judith asserted. So listening to the rest of the series back at home on the radio was almost as good. But it was in game 5 that the Tigers found their hero as Mickey Lolich won his second game of the series, beating the Cardinals’ Nelson Briles 5-3. Lolich had pitched a complete game winner in game two and provided the first glimmer of hope.Â
Then came the crucial game six. Although many don’t really see it as a difference maker, it was one of two crucial calls by Mayo Smith that set the Tigers up with a chance for a game seven.
Throughout the series Smith relied largely on his two dominant starters, Denny McLain and Mickey Lolich. He had Earl Wilson who had pitched well and there was Joe Sparma.  But Wilson started only game three of the World Series and other than that it was McLain and Lolich for the other six games. That meant that in game six Mayo Smith had to ask Denny McLain to come back on only two days rest.Â
It is easy to forget that McLain was the ace of the staff in 1968. His career went into such a sharp nose dive after 1968. But in ’68 he won 31 games and pitched to an ERA of 1.96–far better than the numbers Lolich put up that year.  McLain had been roughed up in the series. In the first game the two aces–Gibson and McLain–faced off and Gibson made it look effortless.Â
In the first game in St. Louis he pitched a complete game shutout striking out seventeen Tigers. McLain on the other hand was very hittable, giving up three runs in a disappointing five innings. Gibson beat him even worse in game four. He again went the distance while McLain failed to make it out of the third inning. The Cards won 10-1.Â
At that point it looked like the Tigers were done. The Cardinals led in the series by a 3 games to 1 margin and were returning home. Sure, Mickey Lolich was a good pitcher, but the Cardinals and Bob Gibson had established their dominance and even rabid fans with a dog in the fight like Judith Wolfe got discouraged.
When Mayo Smith decided to bring back Denny McLain on two days rest for the sixth game in St. Louis’ Busch Stadium, it looked like it would end then and there. Hall of Fame manager, Red Schoendienst stuck with his plan going with Ray Washburn. He gave Gibson the extra day of rest for a game seven if needed.
McLain did something he did less and less in the years to come, he rewarded Mayo Smith for putting his confidence in the Tigers’ star. McLain put the Tigers in a position to win the 1968 World Series by beating the odds and the Cardinals. On October 9th, by a score of 10-1, the Tigers won game six.Â
It was a complete game win for McLain and the shellacking shifted the momentum back in the direction of the Tigers. Sure, Gibson was pitching game seven, but the Tiger bats had come alive in game six.
Judith Wolfe remembers exactly what she was doing the day of the seventh game. She was a social worker who had to drive a young child to Philadelphia that day. She set out in the car with the radio tuned to the series and all the way there and all the way back she was glued to the action, hanging on every pitch by Lolich and Gibson. It became a matter of which one would break first as each put up one scoreless frame after another.Â
Gibson did not give any ground in the first three innings. He was perfect. Nine batters faced, nine outs and six by strikeout. By comparison Lolich labored through those innings but made it with the score still tied, 0-0. The difference came in the sixth inning. The great Lou Brock led off with a single. A single by Brock was as good as a double, but this time Lolich won the game of cat and mouse. He picked the Hall of Fame base-stealer off first base. Then Curt Flood got a single and Lolich did it again, picking Flood off base.Â
Those two plays were the first sign the tide had turned. Lolich blunted the force of the Cardinal running game and in the seventh inning the Tigers took command of the game.  A Jim Northrup triple scored Norm Cash and Willie Horton for the first runs of the game. A Bill Freehan double brought Northrup in and made the score 3-0. The game ended 4-1 almost anti-climatically with Lolich in total control.
Judith Wolfe believes that her dad’s best move wasn’t just pitching McLain in game six, it was playing Mickey Stanley at shortstop so Al Kaline could play full time in the outfield. Her father pulled as many strings as he could that October. They worked well enough to bring the World Championship home to Detroit in the year after the ’67 race riots. It served to bring pride back to a city torn at its heart.Â
It was Mayo Smith’s finest hour and the fans of Detroit have rewarded him with the Mayo Smith Society that exists for fans to this day. Mayo Smith died in 1977 after retiring in 1970. But he had a hell of a finish in 1968, one that we will all remember.










I recently find a Mayo Smith baeball card nsiode a wall of an old home. Just curious as to how much it would be worht??