Nolan Ryan
January 3, 2008 by Michael Hoban · 5 Comments
Nolan Ryan is a Hall of Fame pitcher – there is no question about that. But exactly how good was he and how does he compare to the other HOF pitchers? People are usually surprised when I explain that Nolan Ryan’s career more closely resembles that of Don Sutton than those of truly outstanding pitchers […]
Thank You and Happy New Year!
January 1, 2008 by Mike Lynch · Leave a Comment
We here at Seamheads.com would like to thank those of you who visited the site in 2007 as well as those who have either bookmarked or linked to us. We really appreciate you and hope you come back. In less than three months we’ve attracted more than 20,000 visitors, who’ve accounted for almost 500,000 hits! […]
A Short Career – The Pitchers
December 26, 2007 by Michael Hoban · 3 Comments
The NEWS HOF Gauge recognizes two small groups of pitchers as having HOF numbers even though they did not reach the NEWS criterion of 235 for a starting pitcher. 1. The 180/2400 Standard – Starters and starter/reliever There are only five pitchers in the 20th century who have attained a NEWS score of 180 while […]
A Short Career and the HOF
December 19, 2007 by Michael Hoban · Leave a Comment
According to the NEWS HOF Gauge, only eighty-four (84) position players in the 20th century have attained HOF numbers with a NEWS score of 280. That is a very select club. But there were nine other position players who also achieved HOF numbers even though they had relatively short careers. There have only been eleven […]
Macdonald Lays Down Sacrifice, Everyone Wins
December 12, 2007 by Mike Lynch · 1 Comment
Larry Macdonald, a good friend of mine for the last 10 years or so, and an original member of the Seamheads.com Diamond Kings Baseball League, made a sacrifice for another friend that makes me proud to know him. Macdonald donated a kidney to Jim Rosenbeck, a friend he’d met while playing in the same fantasy […]
HOF Election “Rigged?â€
December 5, 2007 by Michael Hoban · 21 Comments
Marvin Miller was not elected to the Hall of Fame by the Veterans’ Committee on Dec. 3, 2007 and he was upset. This is some of what he said (as reported by the Associated Press). “I think it was rigged, but not to keep me out. It was rigged to bring some of these (people) […]
2008 BBWAA Hall of Fame Ballot
December 3, 2007 by Michael Hoban · 7 Comments
The NEWS HOF Gauge (based on Win Shares) has set performance standards for players and pitchers in order to determine whether they have the numbers to be considered serious candidates for the Hall of Fame. These are tough standards as is evidenced by the fact that only 93 position players and 49 pitchers (who played […]
The Best Players NOT in the Hall of Fame
November 26, 2007 by Michael Hoban · Leave a Comment
According to the NEWS HOF Gauge (based on win shares), at the end of the 2006 season, only 82 position players had established a NEWS score of 280 (clear HOF numbers). In the 2007 season, Chipper Jones and Jim Thome joined this elite group. Jones is now the #79 best position player of the 20th […]
WIN SHARES and the HALL OF FAME
November 23, 2007 by Michael Hoban · 2 Comments
In 2002, Bill James published his book called WIN SHARES in which he introduced a new system that was the product of more than twenty-five years of research. And it is this system that I am convinced is far better than any other that has been developed for comparing players. The method is so revolutionary […]
Numbers and the Hall of Fame
November 16, 2007 by Michael Hoban · Leave a Comment
This is the first in a series of short articles and/or comments that I will be writing regarding baseball’s Hall of Fame. Who belongs in the Hall of Fame? According to the guidelines set forth for the BBWAA election process, “Voting shall be based upon the player’s record, playing ability, integrity, sportsmanship, character, and contributions […]
The Top 40 Pitchers of the 20th Century
November 8, 2007 by Michael Hoban · Leave a Comment
Bill James’ WIN SHARES system is the ultimate baseball statistic currently available to judge exactly how good a season a player had. That is the view of Dr. Michael Hoban -retired mathematics professor and serious baseball analyst. And that is why the professor has used WIN SHARES in his new book to create a new […]
The Top 100 Position Players of the 20th Century
November 7, 2007 by Michael Hoban · 2 Comments
Bill James’ WIN SHARES system is the ultimate baseball statistic currently available to judge exactly how good a season a player had. That is the view of Dr. Michael Hoban -retired mathematics professor and serious baseball analyst. And that is why the professor has used WIN SHARES in his new book to create a new […]
Ted Williams: Part II
November 5, 2007 by Mike Lynch · Leave a Comment
I received a lot of feedback about my Ted Williams article in which I opined that Williams was the greatest hitter who ever lived and presented my case by combining Williams’ real stats with five years’ worth of simulated stats that were generated by Micro League Baseball, a computer baseball game that came out in […]
Who, You Ask, is Tiny Bonham?
October 29, 2007 by Mike Lynch · 3 Comments
While watching last night’s game in which the Red Sox copped their second World Series title in four years, Fox flashed a graphic on the screen that showed that Red Sox rookie Jon Lester was only the third pitcher in history to win the clinching game in his first postseason start, the others being W. […]
Baseball’s Best: Chapter Five Excerpt Added
October 25, 2007 by Mike Lynch · Leave a Comment
Yet another chapter excerpt from Mike Hoban’s book, Baseball’s Best: The TRUE Hall of Famers, has been added to the site. In Chapter Five, Dr. Hoban asks whether or not it’s fair to use the same criteria to evaluate short but great careers, like that of Jackie Robinson, and longer careers. He evaluates the careers […]
Baseball’s Best: Chapter Four Excerpt Added
October 24, 2007 by Mike Lynch · Leave a Comment
Another chapter excerpt from Mike Hoban’s book, Baseball’s Best: The TRUE Hall of Famers, has been added to the site. In Chapter Four, Dr. Hoban discusses 38 position players who are in the Hall of Fame and uses his NEWS HOF Monitor scores to determine whether or not they have the numbers worthy of the […]
Sorry Joe, This Time You Got It Wrong
October 21, 2007 by Michael Hoban · 2 Comments
I have always liked Joe Torre – admiring his class and his style. And, like most followers of the game, I have never liked George Steinbrenner. But, at his press conference on Oct. 18, Joe got it all wrong. St. Joe did not come across as a martyr to me. He came across as a […]
Out of Left Field: Three Cheers for Joe Torre
October 19, 2007 by Mike Lynch · 3 Comments
I never thought I’d say this about a Yankee, but I love Joe Torre. That’s right, I have a major man crush on the former Yankee skipper after he told George Steinbrenner and his sons, Uday and Qusay, where they could stick their ridiculous contract offer. It wasn’t the amount that was ridiculous—if you’ve been […]
The TRUE Hall of Famers: Excerpts added
October 16, 2007 by Mike Lynch · Leave a Comment
As promised I’ve posted chapter excerpts from Dr. Michael Hoban’s book, Baseball’s Best: The TRUE Hall of Famers. I’ve also included a list of the 25 best position players and pitchers from the 20th century. Check it out!
Out of Left Field: ALCS Game 2
October 14, 2007 by Mike Lynch · 6 Comments
While watching last night’s ALCS game between the Red Sox and Indians, I decided to take notes and write down my thoughts as they occurred. Here they are. At the start of the game Joe Buck asserted that Curt Schilling was a Hall of Famer. Schilling doesn’t feel like a Hall of Famer to me, […]
Baseball’s Best: The TRUE Hall of Famers
October 13, 2007 by Mike Lynch · 2 Comments
Seamheads.com is featuring a new book written by Dr. Michael Hoban, a professor emeritus from City University of New York and a longtime SABR member. Dr. Hoban has used Bill James’ Win Shares system to come up with a new Hall of Fame monitor score in an effort to determine which players truly deserve to […]
Is Boston Really Under More Pressure Than Cleveland?
October 10, 2007 by Mike Lynch · 1 Comment
This morning while driving to work I was listening to ESPN’s Colin Cowherd talk about the upcoming ALCS and he was of the opinion that Cleveland has the edge over Boston because the Red Sox are under more pressure to win, the Indians’ aces are better than Boston’s, and because Cleveland has better middle relief. […]
Dice-K and the Vanishing Strike Zone
October 8, 2007 by Mike Lynch · 3 Comments
Now that the Red Sox have easily dispatched the Angels and we’re all waiting breathlessly for the outcome of the Indians/Yankees series, it’s time to vent my frustration on Daisuke “Dice-K†Matsuzaka and his performance, or lack thereof, in Game 2 of the ALDS (I’ll vent on Eric Gagne another day). Going into the game […]
White Stocking Stuffers (#385)
December 17, 2006 by Gene Carney · Leave a Comment
There was so much more I wanted to get into this issue, but I just ran out of time and space. Look for one more issue in ’06. A NOTE FROM JIM ELFERS Last issue, I reviewed Jim’s book, The Tour to End All Tours, and received this note, which I pass along with Jim’s […]
NOTES #142
July 28, 1996 by Gene Carney · Leave a Comment
NOTES FROM THE SHADOWS OF COOPERSTOWN Observations from Outside the Lines By Two Finger Carney (carneya6@adelphia.net) #142 JULY 28, 1996 PEANUTS AND CRACKER JACK That’s the heading I use for pages where I collect all kinds of unrelated baseball stuff, and this is that kind of issue. No main theme, no big events, just a […]
NOTES #140
July 16, 1996 by Gene Carney · Leave a Comment
NOTES FROM THE SHADOWS OF COOPERSTOWN Observations from Outside the Lines By Two Finger Carney (carneya6@borg.com) #140 July 16, 1996 ONE OLD CAT One old cat is a game that is older than baseball, and is usually considered an ancestor. Rules vary, but it’s a ball and stick game, with running and bases, hits and […]
NOTES #126
March 23, 1996 by Gene Carney · Leave a Comment
NOTES FROM THE SHADOWS OF COOPERSTOWN Observations from Outside the Lines By Two Finger Carney (carneya6@borg.com) #126 MARCH 23, 1996 GONE FISHING “‘I would like to take the great DiMaggio fishing,’ the old man said. ‘They say his father was a fisherman. Maybe he was as poor as we are and would understand.’” I enjoyed […]
NOTES #125
March 17, 1996 by Gene Carney · Leave a Comment
St Patrick Invented Baseball I have suspected for some time that I’ve always felt at home in the country of baseball, partly because of my ancestry. Both of my grandfathers, long gone from the planet long before I arrived, were Irish. So what? Well, if you look closely at the hairs on baseball’s head, you […]
Some Reflections on Pete Rose
October 20, 1995 by Gene Carney · Leave a Comment
Some Reflections on Pete Rose From NOTES #116, October 20, 1995: PONDERING PETE ROSE, 1995 I was living in Cleveland when Pete Rose torpedoed Ray Fosse, but I think I disliked the guy even before then. I certainly respected him when he was hustling hits. He was, in a way, the John Kruk of his […]
Notes #77
August 3, 1994 by Gene Carney · Leave a Comment
NOTES FROM THE SHADOWS OF COOPERSTOWN Observations from Outside the Lines By Two Finger Carney (carneya6@adelphia.net) #77 August 3, 1994 TAKING TIME FOR PARADISE Americans and Their Games was Giamatti’s subtitle for his small but tedious book with the wonderful title I’ve borrowed, and it could fit nicely as the subtitle for my week on […]
STRIKEOUT: When Mudville Stood Still
May 6, 1994 by Gene Carney · Leave a Comment
Notes #52
February 5, 1994 by Gene Carney · Leave a Comment
NOTES FROM THE SHADOWS OF COOPERSTOWN Observations from Outside the Lines By Two Finger Carney (carneya6@adelphia.net) #52 — AKA: Hot Stove Issue #14 February 5, 1994 WHAT MAKES FOR A GOOD HOT STOVE QUESTION? The logs that burns longest and hottest are the kind I like in my hot stove. Trivia questions are like newspaper: […]
Notes #20
June 27, 1993 by Gene Carney · Leave a Comment
NOTES FROM THE SHADOWS OF COOPERSTOWN Observations from Outside the Lines By Two Finger Carney (carneya6@adelphia.net) #20 June 27, 1993 Week Twelve: June 21 – 27 WHO WAS THAT LADY I HEARD YOU WITH LAST NIGHT? A question I wanted to ask Gary Cohen, after tuning in the Mets for a while on June 5th, […]









